1998 Watford
1999 Not Awarded
2000 Huddersfield
2001 Brentford
2002 Hull City
2003 Grimsby Town
2004 Tranmere Rovers
2005 Watford
2006 Preston North End
2007 Preston North End
2008 Watford
2009 West Ham United
2010 Kidderminster Harriers
2011 Ipswich Town
2012 Watford
2013 AFC Chorley
2014 West Ham United
2015 Bury B
2016 Gillingham
2017 Grimsby Town
2018 AFC Halifax
2019 Northampton Town
2020 Luton Town
2021 Luton Town
2022 Glasgow Piraten